Tuesday, May 20, 2014

May 27…On Labaree’s Scholar-Practitioner Tension

Note something from this article with which you disagree (note: I assume that reading this paper was a different experience for those with P-12 experience and those without.  That said, he made a sufficient number of bold claims so I’m sure everyone can disagree with something he said). Why do you disagree with it?  Did Labaree give words to any tensions that you feel as you head down the road of the educational researcher?  If so, explain.

20 comments:

  1. I really enjoyed reading Labaree’s article and actually agreed with most of his points. He does make some strong statements about the differences between being a teacher and being a researcher, but as he says, “the gap is not as wide as it seems” (p. 21). One point that he makes about how teachers focus on getting things right in the classroom rather than getting things right in their head, made me cringe. On p. 18 he talks about how education professors push their students to look at education as an object of analysis but teachers have a hard time with that because they bring a normative view of education to the table. This might be true in the beginning of a program but I don’t know any teacher that feels our education system is perfect and that it can’t be analyzed to find trends to improve it. Teachers analyze education every day in the teacher’s lounge. Now I know that their “analysis” is coming from a different perspective but if they are in an education program, they should be able to step back and, with assistance from professors, be able to analyze education from a different lens. Labaree says that this normative perspective leads to an approach to scholarship that he describes as unrealistic and comically optimistic – “one that suggest that there is an implementable answer to every educational problem and that help is always on the way” (p. 18). I feel that this is something that the faculty needs to assist former or current teachers with because that view has only been reinforced by the system. In all the county initiatives and professional development I have experienced (and provided) it has been sold by pointing out a problem and then learning the strategy that will “fix” said problem. As future researchers, teachers need to let go of this way of thinking, but through good instruction by education professors, I do not see this as a huge problem.
    As far as my experience as a future educational researcher in this program, I have not had a problem stepping back from the classroom perspective and seeing education issues and research from a wider perspective. I think I will always internalize information first with my teacher hat on, but know that my own experiences are minute compared to the bigger picture. I think the various positions I have had both being a teacher and working with teachers helps in this flexibility.

    ReplyDelete
  2. “From the teacher’s perspective, the scholarly approach to education may seem coldly distant and unconscionably unconcerned about student outcomes.” (p. 18)

    It’s not so much that I disagree with this statement as much as it struck a nerve upon reading it, which I guess more accurately answers the second portion of your question rather than the first. My subsequent response to this quote is twofold: 1) researchers are neither coldly distant or unconcern with student outcomes and 2) do teachers accurately make the distinction between educational researchers and policymakers/test-makers.

    I have never taught in a classroom (past student teaching), so I consider myself a researcher and not a teacher. As a researcher, I think I am a caring and compassionate being. I use theory to formulate ideas about how to make education better. My overarching goal is not to compete with other countries or to make tons of money; rather, I wish to uncover the best possible practices relating to education. I do not believe this makes me “coldly distant” and “unconcerned about student outcomes.” In fact, I would argue it’s the opposite. I know that at times, researchers are VERY distant from the classroom. However, the whole line of our work is to improve student outcomes. We live and breathe to find ways to make all students succeed. Teachers may look at us as mere observers who are removed from the everyday struggles in a class. In fact, this article made mention of “doctoral students are afforded the luxury of playing researcher and not managing a classroom.” Is this really a luxury? We are burdened with the task of FIXING the educational system. Think about it, it is impossible to fix the educational system if we are not interested in student outcomes, which brings me to my second point. I cannot confidently say that teachers make the distinction between test-makers/policymakers and educational researchers (I am making this argument because I honestly do not know). I feel like the field of education is constantly being pushed into a standardized test-taking world and people are pointing the finger at anyone and everyone. As a researcher, I am intrigued by the phenomenon (go ahead and call me cold), but I am not confident that it is the best for our students. Therefore, I would suggest scaling down standardized tests because our field is more “mushy” and not really standardizable. I am not a test-maker or policy person pushing for these tests. Yes, some researchers probably strongly support it, but not all of us do. So please, stop calling us “cold” and “unconcerned.” I do not believe we are these things.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Molly-

      I think you nailed the problem on the head. Researchers are easily lumped into the policymaker/standardized tests population. By being associated with the 'distant' law makers, teachers see the tests as an inaccurate measure of student outcomes and not sensitive to all students, i.e. special education population. However, there are a few policymakers who have managed a classroom, and those researchers, who are not engrossed with the day-to-day happenings of a classroom, who can still see the big picture. It seems that there is actually the common goal of changing the 'enterprise'.

      Taryn

      Delete
  3. I was totally with Larabee and worried that I was reading the wrong article for this prompt until I got to page 17 and started finding things that felt a bit off. For instance, I disagreed with Larabee when he wrote "This [normative] perspective is deeply rooted in the practice of teaching, which necessarily puts a premium on doing what is best for the student" and "Not only are teachers imposing a particular curriculum on students, then, but they are also denying them the liberty to do something else. [...] You had better be able to show that the student ultimately benefits and that these benefits are large enough to justify the coercive means to produce them."

    The problem with these statements is that they make a lot of assumptions about teachers and what's "best" for students. I will admit that during my years of teaching, there were many times when I did not follow the curriculum closely and openly criticized it. Some things that are "best" for some students are not necessarily "best" for other students, and depending on the educational context (for instance, I taught college freshmen for ten years) what's "best" for the majority is arguable. Are easy As best? Is a selective admissions policy best? Is considering the larger social implications of lesson, even if it upsets a few students, best? Larabee should have given his language closer consideration here.

    The next place where I disagreed with Larabee was on page 18, when he said "A university faculty position gives professors the time and space to do research. [...] The [classroom teacher] job is to teach the required curriculum to students at an appropriate level of effectiveness." I have never taught in k-12, but I did teach as an adjunct college instructor for five years and then as a full-time non-tenure track college instructor for six years, and, honestly, this statement pissed me off. I realized as I finished his article that he never addressed the issue of the "adjunctification" of higher education and the line between "teaching" faculty, who are (supposedly!) evaluated on teaching alone, and "traditional" faculty, who (Larabee says) have all of this luxurious time to do research. As an instructor for undergraduate students, my job was pretty much to "teach the required curriculum at an appropriate level of effectiveness." This is the reality for many college teachers. I wonder what will happen if the tide continues to go in the direction of more instructor/non-tenture track faculty, and what this will do to the divide between teaching and research at universities. For instance, I know that VCU's School of Education relies on adjuncts for a number of their undergraduate teacher-training classes. I wonder how those instructors would react to Larabee's assertions...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ginger -

      As one who is interested in bridging the gap between research and practice, I see your point regarding adjunct faculty as very important. Adjunct faculty are seen as still having their finger on the pulse of what is going on in education. These faculty members are teachers, administrators, and educational specialists. It is thought that preservice teachers connect with adjunct faculty better because there is not a large gap in perspectives. However, I am an adjunct faculty member who is very interested in research and the global issues in education.

      There should not be such a large gap between research and practice. However, in talking to administrators in public schools, they want to know why they have to pay for additional professional development to teach teachers how to teach new practices and stay on top of the best practices in the field. Is this because we aren't teaching teachers to be researchers? Just food for thought.

      Taryn

      Delete
  4. I think that Labaree’s distinction between educators and researchers in the doctoral and school of education contexts exists in large part because of a flawed understanding of the moral imperative underneath the two endeavors. He states that there is “an element of teaching that is irreducibly moral” (p. 17). He then describes school as not meeting the direct needs of a client, which he claims, is the student. However, in the educational context, students are not the client, society is. As such, teachers are tasked with meeting those societal needs before any students’ needs are met. This is not to say that teachers are not moral as individuals, many go to incredible lengths for their students, but the profession is not one situated in morality. Rather, it is a way to promote social efficiency. Since this “morality” is societally based, and response on the part of individual teachers will be directly related to what society says.

    This inherent “morality” makes former educators entering schools of education as students valuable in Labaree’s eyes. I would argue that overreliance on this prior experience can be harmful in the long run, by limiting perspectives and focus (again, speaking in generalities). If schools of education continue to be dominated by former teachers, their agendas will not be able to be untangled from what society currently is. A reactionary approach is not enough if real change is a desired outcome. I would suggest that it is perhaps more important to attract students without formal experience in teaching to the stage: our metaphorical cups are empty. We can perhaps be closer to “morality” by nature of our lack of tempering in the fires of the field. By not carrying with us more reactionary perspectives, it may be possible to create a more complete image of certain issues that might lead to better results. I recognize that Labaree sees that values of both perspectives, but his choice to tie value to certain perspectives without due consideration of the context might put this lens into question.

    ReplyDelete
  5. As pointed out in the article, Labaree does state that the gap between teachers and researchers isn’t as wide as it seems and that the gap is not a pure dichotomy, yet the rhetoric and claims in this article seem to overshadow these earlier warnings. The article laid the foundation down for some good points, but a lot of my disagreements in the article (similar to the ones already stated) made me wonder if my main objection was just that the article is outdated. For example, Ginger brought up a great point about adjunct/teaching professors, which I would venture is a more prominent problem in recent years, than in 2003 when the article was published. Similarly, I agree with Molly’s argument that researchers aren’t coldly distant, most educational researchers I know are actually in the classrooms and interacting with students & teachers/forming relationships. Is this because qualitative research, while still not favored, is more accepted today than back in 2003? I agree with that statement that teachers’ often look for practical solutions, but my agreement ends there. I don’t believe that this impulse, “often leads students to frame their own research around educational success stories. The idea is to pick an intervention that promises to improve education…” (p. 18). Most of the teachers I know are tired of trying a new intervention/quick fix routinely before there is even a chance to see an effect. I think teachers know there is not an answer to every problem. Is this again, an outdated argument now that teachers’ curriculums are more prescribed in today’s society? I would be interested to see what a revision of this article would look like as the education world (both researchers’ and teachers’) has shifted quite a bit from 2003.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Labaree nailed some of the sentiments I have been feeling but have not succinctly articulated regarding the nature of education research. Although I have been out of the classroom for many years, on more than one occasion during the past year of doctoral studies I’ve been critical of the removed distance of education research. Too often researchers seem only to give a nod to the realities of the classroom with a paragraph at the end of an article focusing on “applications to teaching” that seems more of a hollow formality than a true interest in how the research connects to the classroom.

    However, I see the value Labaree points to in an applying analytical, intellectual and universal approaches and he is thoughtful in his explanation of the real and practical reasons for P-12 teachers’ worldviews. I can’t outright find something to disagree about with Labaree, but I believe the scope of his article falls short in one area that may be more prevalent in our current era of high-stakes test and accountability. I would venture that a new crop of teacher-turned doctoral students may enter their programs with a frustration about the misapplication of education research that may lead them in search of more than the narrowly focused practical solutions to classroom and student problems. My conversations with colleagues in the program who are still in, or recently exited, the classroom causes me to believe that they are indeed interested in bigger (although maybe not theoretical?) questions that address the direction public education is headed.

    My question is whether doctoral programs will offer them (us?) an outlet that addresses that frustration and looks for avenues to build on that frustration, if it indeed it is widespread. I’m curious about what Labaree would write if he were to update this article today. Furthermore, although Labaree doesn’t address this issue, it seems that researchers often equate the very act of conducting valid research as an end in itself. Is that enough? Or should researchers be held “accountable” for how their research is being used and applied? Would that narrow the cultural divide between researchers and teachers?

    ReplyDelete
  7. Like Heather, I also seem to agree with the broad strokes of most of what Labaree had to say in this piece. I particularly liked his note of “enjoy(ing) the luxury of being the observer for once rather than the person in charge…” (p. 19). It is true that practitioners are often busy addressing the particular and that there exists little time to ponder universal truths, and this reminder of my new status as a researcher is comforting. This, among other reasons, was one of my motivations for pursuing doctoral work in the first place. Now I have the luxury to investigate specific things that interest me in education… something that I maybe didn’t have the time to do when I had to do things like take attendance four times in four different places each day.

    There were a couple of claims made in this article that I am not sure I fully endorse. The assertion that new doctoral students feel that they are “being asked to abandon teacher culture in favor of a new academic culture” (p. 14) is not completely in line with my experience in schools of education in my two masters programs and in this doctoral program. Teacher experience has always been something that has been valued and the culture of teaching is a part of that. To the contrary, I have sometimes felt bad for my non-teacher colleagues. While they bring their own unique and important perspectives, the fact that they are not “part of the club” (of teachers) can be exclusionary at times I would suppose.

    I would also offer a bit of push back to the claim that “researchers are pressed to develop understandings of problems… that are most urgent at a particular time.” (p. 14) This may indeed be true to an extent; the issues of the day in our field are often topics of interest for researchers. However, a common complaint from researchers is that they do research that is pertinent, but policymakers do not listen to them. Good research takes time, often more time than politicians are willing to allow when they get an itch to “fix something.” And while Labaree is in part correct with what he is saying here, I feel that this is also a knock on the practical relevance of educational research.

    ReplyDelete
  8. While I fully understand the importance of this article and the fact that is does speak to a very large audience, I can't help but think "what about those of us who weren't teachers?" I'm fairly certain he does not assume that all educational researchers were at one time in the classroom (and I know MANY who never were) but that audience is completely missing. Are we less worthy of being educational researchers? More worthy? I know his point was to talk about teachers -> researchers specifically but I couldn't help but wonder where the rest of us fall.

    While is did agree with a lot of what Labaree said and disagreed with some of his statements, one statement that kept sitting at the forefront while I attempted to read was that regardless of whether we use qualitative or quantitative research, it is difficult to conduct credible research in the field of education. Credible? Is that really what he means? Not credible research? I kept coming back to that statement and had to make myself keep reading before posting on the blog. Yes, it is an EXTREMELY difficult context to conduct research in. But not credible? Maybe I'm overanalyzing this sentence (not that I overanalyze anything...ever) but it seems to me that as long as we are transparent about our work and upfront in saying "this may not generalize", I think our work is more than credible. It is a messy, messy reality we seek to understand and disentangle but I think if we are thoughtful about what questions we ask and how we approach gathering an answer, we can uncover some meaningful information and insight that can be used to meet our individual goals.

    This thought just popped into my head, and I won't elaborate on it much but I have decided I don't like the comparison of education to "hard sciences" and I would like to yell at the first person to ever do such a thing. Let the chemists do their thing in "gold standard land". Spoiler alert: 2 parts hydrogen and 1 part oxygen will always make water. Their world is far different from our world and the two shouldn't even be in the same article BUT I believe our work is equally as credible (given that it is conducted using best practices and in an ethical manner).

    ReplyDelete
  9. When I told a former professor that I was leaving the classroom in order to try to make changes from the academy, she told me that she is considering leaving the academy because she feels that she can make a bigger impact from the classroom. In this short vignette, I feel the dichotomy between researcher and teacher. However, in many of the schools of education that I have encountered, the universities try to make connections with the P-12 school systems in order to make connections and break the dichotomy.

    I think the quote that Molly discussed and Stefani followed up with is an important consideration to make. It might seem to teachers that scholars are coldly distant because, as Labaree states, researchers aren’t dealing with the day-to-day grind of the classroom. However, it’s important to have someone to do research to make sure that students are receiving the best education possible. I very much believe in action research and other research methods as professional development for teachers. However, this is generally accompanied by complaining of a lack of time. (At least my colleagues complained about such directives. And I understand that time is limited, but we can’t accept mediocrity as “good enough.”) That being said, research is an important aspect of the educational world. I’m sure that part of the problem is that teachers see researchers as “possible extra work.” Again, partnerships are important.

    Laberee also discusses the role of teacher experience: “…at any point in the discussion of an academic paper, the student can (and, in my experience, frequently does) introduce an example from his or her practitioner experience that automatically trumps any claim made by the authors” (p. 20). I understand Laberee’s frustration with students using experience as a way to counter a point made by a researcher, but since the field is so applied, each situation is slightly different. I think it’s not a good idea to discount teacher experience (we could go so far to call it auto-ethnographical, but that’s a stretch, because these experiences were not usually designed to be empirical studies), but it is important to find a balance between empirical data and experience. Educational research (including teacher prep) really is like the yin and the yang. You need the perfect balance of both, and discounting one for the other is perilous.

    ReplyDelete


  10. Labaree (2003) was an interesting read. Sometimes the truth hurts and I felt uncomfortable while reading the first section of the article that mirrored our discussion in class about the “Rodney Dangerfield” image of education. My initial reaction was to assume a position of defensiveness and cry from the rooftop a heartfelt “No! We are better than that!” However, this would not be reasonable nor effective especially given recent tornadoes, earthquakes, my fear of heights, and the fact that Labaree’s words are rooted in truth. Labaree expands on this theme describing the “weak position” of educational researchers and the “lowly status” of schools of education. I found this section to be personally depressing and defeatist. However, it is important to know the history of the field as well as the current state in order to forge ahead with a clear, realistic understanding and a sense of purpose. This also fuels within me with a determination to produce quality research and a desire to become a steward of the field. A question for my colleagues, “How can we as educational researchers and leaders advance and elevate the field of education?”

    My thoughts about Lararee’s divisive discussion of educational researchers versus teachers mirror many previously articulated by my peers. To add to the discussion, Labaree describes the experience of teachers turned researchers as pushed to “think and act in ways that are essential for the emerging scholar but highly suspect from the perspective of the teacher: to read extensively and intensively in the literature on education, critique and synthesize the ideas in this literature, develop cogent arguments about educational issues, and use data and logic to validate these arguments. All of this may seem to these students like so much intellectual fiddling while the classroom burns” (p.18). Highly suspect? Intellectual fiddling? This argument seems to greatly underestimate the intellectual and analytical abilities of teachers and echoes the earlier theme of disrespect for educators. Labaree also argues the personal and professional capacities that make one a good teacher don’t matter in the “idea-entered world of a doctoral program.” In addition to the analytical laundry list provided above, I believe that experience, interpersonal insight, and common sense are essential in conducting meaningful research. While the purpose of a research program may be idea centered, the focus of those ideas is to inform and improve teaching practice. Rather than a liability, I view the highly contextualized nature of education as a unique strength of the field. Yes, this does present challenges as described by Labaree, but it also offers the potential for a powerful partnership between practice and research that can create meaningful change.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Labaree’s discussion of the gaps between education practitioners and researchers echoed many of the frustrations I’ve been grappling with over the last year, both as a new doctoral student and in my current work situation. One statement in particular struck me. On page 17, he writes, “if teaching is a highly normative practice, which focuses on the effort to produce valued outcomes, then educational researcher is a distinctly more analytical practice, which focuses on the effort to produce valid explanations.” While Labaree goes on later to discuss the importance of narrowing the gaps between these two outcomes-based approaches, the distinction between the research focus on “valid explanations” versus “valued outcomes” is one with which I have a lot of problems. This year, a large research firm approached me about doing a large-scale randomized study to look at the effectiveness of the workforce programs I coordinate. By insisting on a randomized study we had to turn away a pretty large number of qualified candidates and refer them to adult education programs that had not been successful for them in the past. In this case, as the practitioner and not the researcher, I was ethically opposed to the process, and we did, in the end, decide to end the study. Here the need for “valid explanations” as to how this program was working trumped our need for “valued outcomes”, and we saw the design of the study as an amoral intrusion.
    I have respect for the “analytical, intellectual, theoretical, and universalistic orientations of the researcher” (p. 21), but I feel strongly that research should not be conducted in a way that purposefully disadvantages learners. Labaree writes about the value of learning about education “by examining it as an outsider, as a researcher” (p. 21), but there needs to be a limit to how impersonal and how distant research is from the population it studies.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. By the way, this is Kate. Apparently, I had a BlogSpot account maybe 5 years ago when I lived on Nansemond. Who knew?

      Delete
  12. Overall, I enjoyed reading the piece. I think Tami summed it up well by saying that this article makes many claims that I have often thought, but was never able to fully verbalize. One major disputation I would have with Labaree though would be the assertion that "professional experience" is both entirely common in educational researchers and that it is an asset in research itself.

    Labaree clearly realizes that education as a field of study is diverse, complicated and difficult to understand holistically. However, when he claims that experience is beneficial to the researcher, he paints experienced classroom teachers with a very broad brush. He says "they have more than an abstract conception of the subject they will be studying in their doctoral program." (p. 16) He elaborates and claims that classroom teachers both dominate the pool of educational researchers and benefit overall from classroom experience. I do not believe either of these to be true in all cases. Personally, I have seven years of classroom experience, but even in those years I have encountered such a focused piece of the field that it is not nearly as beneficial as he is claiming. I've never taught elementary or middle school. I've never taught in rural or urban settings. I've never taught in a state outside of Virginia, or even a district outside of my own. How much does this experience actually help me? In a lot of ways I think that classroom teachers have more to overcome when conducting quality research, because we enter with specific biases and beliefs about education based on our limited experience. Of course it makes sense that an second grade ELL instructor might benefit from this experience when studying second grade ELL education, but would that same experience help the same researcher in a project about Adult Language Learning or even High School extra-curriculars?

    ReplyDelete
  13. Just like David, I have a problem with the sentence on page 14, “teachers who enter doctoral programs ….often feel they are being asked to abandon teacher culture in favor of a new academic culture”. This is not my experience at all with the School of Education here at VCU. I have taken a number of classes in this school and in every one of them I have seen faculty and classmates giving much respect to those who have classroom experience in primary and secondary schools and wanting to hear their views and how they might reconcile new knowledge with what they already possess. In fact there have been times that I have felt envious of my classmates with classroom experience at the K-12 level. I may be naïve but all I see is great appreciation for their experience and nobody really is asking them to abandon their teacher culture for a college academic culture. Who would do that? As adult learners we are experiential learners. So everybody brings their experiences to the learning that is occurring, resulting in a much richer knowledge acquisition. So I would hardly call it “a clash of the K-12 teacher and the university researcher" (page 15) but more like a collaborative relationship that is mutually beneficial.

    As I continued to think about what I had read in the article, I decided that maybe the problem could be that indeed the article is outdated (2003), just like Stephanie mentioned in her posting. So maybe the doctoral program in the college of Education at Michigan State University is not significantly different from the SOE here at VCU. If Dr. Labaree wrote this article today, would he be making the same conclusions? For example, I see that quite a large number of students in our programs here at VCU do not have K-12 classroom experience so some of the nuances that he mentions this experience brings might not be as pronounced as he indicates.

    Also looking at this week’s and last week’s readings, I began to think that even though It is true that doctoral students in education are older and more mature, this is hardly unique for schools of education, it is more like the norm in most doctoral programs. Almost all doctoral nursing students are “grown-ups” for example. The programs with students going straight into doctoral programs are becoming the minority – I may have to do more research to prove this point. So this is not one of the peculiarities of doctoral programs in education.

    ReplyDelete
  14. As someone with no teaching experience, I found the article to be a compelling piece that “made sense.” None of his arguments really raised any specific red flags for me, but the article did leave me feeling a bit…unsettled. A closer reading may change my mind, but I do question how much Larabee feels doctoral programs need to move in narrowing the “cultural gap.” Much of the prescriptions at the end of each section focus on “selling arguments” to the teachers on why they need to expand their perspectives and embrace research. But Larabee doesn’t seem to give much consideration to how doctoral programs might better incorporate teacher perspectives and experiences to help the field of education research grow. Instead, teacher perspectives seem to serve as an “in” to be used in helping train teachers to better understand how educational research should be done.

    I also found him to be surprisingly assertive in his arguments – surprising because, in light of his apparent regard for intellectual and analytic approaches to research, his claims are based on largely (admittedly extensive) personal experience alone. As tempting as it is to trust him and his arguments, I’m left wondering if Larabee accurately presented how P-12 teachers perceive these cultural issues or if he provided an “analytical view” of his own perceptions of how the teachers perceive the issues. Without a better understanding of how/why this article was prepared and without any personal experience as a teacher, I find it hard to pick any one of the arguments as being more or less controversial than the other.

    So, while I wouldn't say that Larabee gives words to any tensions I feel, the article does remind me to be more self-aware of how my own perspectives influence what I do, and maybe even how they can grant or take away legitimacy from my own work. If I were to discover, for instance, that Larabee truly privileges the established academic structure, I would be much more critical of how I read his arguments to be one-sided. On the other hand, if I were to discover he had extensive qualitative research experiences, I’d probably be more accepting of what he wrote.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I'd like to echo many of the same things that I've read from he rest of the class, particularly what Sarah discussed. Being a student who has not experienced the K-12 world I found that this article was slightly bias toward those teachers and against those students who have been more involved with research. Of course I understand the importance of the article and I definitely agree with many of the points that Labaree made throughout but it does make me question myself and other students that do not have the experiences that teachers are said to have. Agreeing with Sarah, are those without teacher experience less equipped or less prepared to be educational researchers? Of course this is not the case but it was something that came to mind when reading the article.

    One quote in particular that I disagreed was on p. 14, "which means that teachers who enter doctoral programs in education often feel they are being asked to abandon teacher culture in favor of a new academic culture." This was interesting to me, maybe because our particular program is really big on maintaining that teacher culture. I am not certain if this is true of other education programs but from my experience the research culture is only supplemental. Even for students who do not have K-12 experience, I have found that the teacher culture is still the focal point of many of our courses. I just believed this was a strange assumption, at least from my experiences.

    I also had a bit of an issue with the negativity that Labaree places on researchers, their objectives, and personalities. His claim that researchers are more distant and are able to avoid the plight of managing a classroom underestimates and downplays the work of the researcher. We all understand that teachers and researchers alike have their own issues but to make that claim was a bit overdone. As I said, I have never been a teacher so I may not fully understand all the issues but at the same time the teachers do not fully understand the issues that researchers face. There are no "luxuries" afforded to either profession and the only way to close the cultural gap that he discusses is to be aware of and respect the differences of the two professions.

    ReplyDelete
  16. This article was very interesting to me personally, as closing this gap between teachers and researchers is a passion of mine.

    On page 18 (the page that made everyone a little uncomfortable), I disagreed with Labaree's comment about the classroom setting making it practically impossible to adopt analytical distance required for scholarship. Yes, teachers do hold a direct responsibility to their students in the classroom. However, teachers juggle many responsibilities at school - sports, clubs, school meetings...let's just say asking too much comes with the territory of 'being a teacher'. I would argue that most teachers want to know and do the most efficient practice that impacts students in a universal way. No one wants to be constantly putting out fires academically and behaviorally. That said, most teachers are not reluctant to embrace analytical practices of scholarship that is relevant. This is a key element to any applied science, relevance. While some may see this as 'soft', it is the nature of the field when dealing with human beings, i.e. morality of education.

    Richardson's use of the word 'enterprise' provides clarity to Labaree's frank statements. As a practitioner, I am currently working with university faculty on changing the systems that train teachers on autism spectrum disorder. We are using assessment measures, standard coaching and teaching procedures, and goal setting to making a better enterprise in the state of Virginia. It made me cringe to read Labaree's statement that said practical solutions, such as the systems change intervention, is 'comically optimistic'. He says to study an intervention in its practice is too micro; however, I see my work as important to the field and am partnering with researchers to make the research grant practical to educators and administrators.

    Optimistic? Maybe, but I think there is a place for both in education. Partnerships, as Mike mentioned, are very imperative to closing this gap in education.

    Taryn

    ReplyDelete
  17. I'm not so sure I appreciate Labaree's remarks regarding the transition of an education from thinking personally to thinking intellectually. The way Labaree phrases it, he makes it seem like one cannot think both personally and intellectually, when that combination seems to be something of an important characteristic in all researchers. We have organizations like the IRB in research institutions to make ensure the safety of subjects, but I argue that the researcher needs to have an initial, personal interest to his or her subject matter to make scientific inquiry worth a damn. I grew up a military brat, and as a researcher, I am drawn to studies that focus on servicemembers and their families. My interest drives me to do hard work and make sure that the research is thorough and intellectual. I wonder, if I didn't have that personal connection to the subject matter, would I work as hard? Or would I be following a rote, paint-by-numbers mindset regarding how to practice research? I'd probably be bored out of my gourd if I had to research something I wasn't remotely interested in, and that would lead to more errors in the research itself. Labaree's statements make it seem like educators don't think like researchers until they get to their doctoral program. I don't feel like this argument holds much water, because many of the social sciences work in the same matter; bachelor's studies introduce topics, master's focus on application, and doctorate studies show you show to become a researcher in your field. He makes similar statements regarding "hard" and "soft" sciences earlier, but doesn't make similar connections later when discussing the mindset of the educational researcher.

    ~Pete Temple!

    ReplyDelete