May 22…On the Nature of a Discipline or Field of Study…Steward of What?
Have you ever thought about the potential for unintended
consequences in acquiring disciplinary expertise? While one might assume that you see the
rewards as worth the risks, this might not be the case, as some of you might be
in the program more for the post-credential opportunities than for a genuine
desire to become an “expert.” How does all of this relate to your situation and
also to the current state of Doctoral
Education in Education?
.f,hzd.fghSDK>FHXK>HD
ReplyDeleteThe most salient unintended consequence in our field would be excessive focus. We are given tools to begin developing research, and are encouraged to dive into an area of interest, but caution needs to be paid in regards to the value of the knowledge we are to obtain. This is less about not “knowing everything about nothing,” but rather given careful thought to the dual nature of being educated in education. If we are to be stewards of education, we must further its goals by not only conducting research, but also by making a place for that research in the live context of schools and the broad system in which we operate. So while a dissertation might be valuable for its theoretical outlook, without the practical needs embedded in this particular field, its total value may be questioned. I feel like there is risk inherent in throwing myself into research without a complete understanding of the contexts in which my research would exist (the more practical components, although it is likely that such an understanding is not actually obtainable in the way I imagine), and so doctoral programs require us to not only be stewards of our fields, but to be stewards of our own thinking inside and outside of that context.
ReplyDeleteAs Jake mentioned in his post, excessive focus is both necessary and has the potential to hinder our ability to be stewards of education. In order to be effective practitioners of research, we must have heightened knowledge about our area of interest or else our input holds no validity or trustworthiness. On the other hand, what is the benefit of this awareness if there is no practical use for this focused knowledge? As researchers and future stewards of education, our research focus must be concentrated, yet translatable to larger audiences. I think some scholars get so engrossed in their personal interests that they forget about having an impact on the field. By keeping up with educational literature outside of your expertise and communicating with colleagues in other fields, I believe researchers develop the reflective practice necessary to enhance practical application of their knowledge.
ReplyDeleteWhen I began the doctoral program, I knew there would be consequences, especially the excessive focus Jake points out, but initially I didn’t view these as negative. I simply accepted these consequences as a rite of passage to receiving your doctorate. No one would look down on me for having such a narrow focus in the field, as that was to be expected from a person with a doctorate. Over the past few weeks, I’ve been questioning my ‘fit’ with my track and the program, as well as my intentions for returning to graduate school. While initially I wanted to return to become an ‘expert’ in the field, I was intimidated by this loaded term. I felt like an academic fraud. I think this led to me questioning my track as I was overwhelmed by the different definitions of education, the different categories of programs within education as well as the breadth and depth of knowledge available. You can’t cover everything within education during your short time in a program, which is why it’s important to strike a balance: between theoretical and the practical, and knowledge and habits. I like how one classmate stated it in class that you can never achieve being an expert, but you can constantly work towards it, which fits the definition of being a steward of both the field and enterprise of education. With the dual nature and meaning of education, being a steward of both the field and of an enterprise is a more balanced, yet meaningful & motivating goal than simply knowing a lot about nothing.
ReplyDeleteI admit, every time I enter a new phase of my academic career, I worry just the tiniest bit about losing two things: perspective and my own identity. Let me clarify the former; I think that I'm going to learn (and have been introduced to) many perspectives within my field of study. But I think of the world as a much, much larger entity. I may become an authority on the subject of special education, but am I an authority limited to the perspectives of those who taught me? Would my own pursuit of knowledge and study of various perspectives outside of my field play any factor in that argument, or will my lens, and my identity be that of "Pete Temple, Doctor of Special Education," and have it end there? It is a somewhat unsettling thought, one that I've tried to combat by broadening the literature I draw from for inspiration. I've picked up a few books on physics, game design, technical manuals on 3D printing...you name it, there's a chance I've got it in my "to read" pile. I think variability is the key to success in any given field, and innovation can be best produced with the injection of ideas sometimes completely different from one's own. I don't know if the traditional "expert" can survive in the current academic, scientific, or economic climate. I think a true expert is one that has dynamic variability, insight to multiple perspectives, and is not afraid to collaborate with others outside of their own field. So far, my actions have served me well. I just hope that the person I become once I earn my doctorate is one who remains fearless, and shoots for the crazier research ideas.
ReplyDeletePete- I was about to write something similar. I really value the inclusion of diverse perspectives in my own knowledge base (specifically I love keeping up with scholarship in world/local history and economics). I'm like you in the sense that I'm not totally sure if it will actually be something of value, but I hope that will be the case. Maybe it's a way to counteract some of these "unintended consequences" people are talking about.
DeleteEarly in my master's program (psychological sciences), I remember one of the professor's in our program asking me about what my initial ideas were for my thesis. When I said "executive functions", she stopped and asked me to clarify what executive functions were. I was flabbergasted. I could not believe someone who called themselves a psychologist didn't know what executive functions were. But, I let it slide given the specificity of the project (and she ended up becoming and still is a dear friend and mentor to me). A few weeks later, it happened again only this time, I wasn't so kind. A fellow student referred to "autistic syndrome". For the remainder of class, I couldn't think of anything but that. How could you call yourself a psychologist or even a psyc major if you can't even accurately identify autism spectrum disorder, I wondered. That got me thinking early on in my graduate career about fields and focus. At that point, I vowed to myself that I would not become one of those who is so focused on their own field/topic that I wouldn't know anything else about other fields in my area of "expertise". I believe that is why I am always eager to jump on projects outside my area and always want to learn about things other than statistics (imagine that!) and use them in conjunction with other content areas. While I believe I am able to learn a whole bunch about a whole bunch, I think that is the case because I force myself to. Doctoral study itself I do not believe is really set up to be that way in part because of the time constraints. We are expected to finish within a reasonable amount of time and in order to do so, it requires focus. Focus on coursework, focus on a dissertation topic, and focus on other things along the way that, ideally, align with the dissertation topic. So, we end up putting ourselves in this little box and we know a whole lot about 1 thing. It's a double edged sword-we should know the history of our field, be current, etc., but the time for doing that is just not there. Unless you're one of those scholars who chooses a topic day 1 of grad school and study that topic your whole career and nothing but that topic, which I'm sure happens...never.
ReplyDeleteI entered my PhD program in educational psychology with a strong background in psychology and have at times struggled with the marriage of education and psychology as reflected in this program, and in the field. In thinking about the unintended consequences of acquiring disciplinary expertise, an idea from Paul (2005) has influenced my thinking. Paul (2005) argues that as disciplinary specialization has increased in the field of educational research, disconnection between specialists and their foundational disciplines has created walls within academia. I have found this to be particularly true in the discipline of educational psychology. Our discipline is educational psychology yet why is there no interaction, connection, or partnership with the department of Psychology? I have felt disconnected from my primary discipline, yet not quite connected within the School of Education, either. As Golde and Walker (2006) point out, only one-third of doctoral students in education have an undergraduate degree in education and I fall outside of that small percentage. I believe that an atmosphere supporting an open exchange of ideas and research would benefit both psychology and education. This is particularly important as understanding education through the lens of psychology relies on the integration of multiple specialties i.e. cognitive, social, motivational, developmental, etc. I believe a risk of an excessively narrow focus is missing out on the bigger picture of the human experience in education.
ReplyDeleteI bring a certain amount of skepticism to the term expert. Experience has taught me that experts too often live in a bubble. In contrast, I view a steward as one who deeply cares for the field, with a desire to grow, protect and hone the field. It is almost as if it is a matter of intent. One who cares will no doubt want to be an expert so they will have the optimum skills to apply to the custody of their field. Thus it seems the goal is to balance expertise with stewardship and that to strike this balance one must possess both breadth and depth in their field and must continually critically reflect upon their own assumptions and the assumptions being made and applied in their field. This relates to my own situation because in my career I’ve been a steward of teachers and public education and with that comes a sense of ownership and commitment to act towards the best ends for those groups. However I must apply the critical perspective mentioned above and guard against thinking there is only one way (my way), recognizing the benefit that multiple perspectives bring to bear on improvement of the field.
ReplyDeleteKate here. My main concerns about unintended consequences echo some of the sentiments that Jake, Pete, and Sarah expressed. I'm in this program to become more of an expert, among other motivations, but I'm leery of losing the perspectives I have now as a practitioner. I don't want to become too focused to lose site of the bigger picture; I also don't want to become too much of an "expert" (or at least consider myself that way) that I subscribe to "expert" models that deny practitioner input. Along the lines of Sarah's comments about putting ourselves in a super-focused box, I also want to keep one foot out of the university/PhD box and one in my actual field. Currently, I work full time in adult education and have opportunities to interact daily with people who deliver services to adult students, and I already feel the effects of this program on those interactions. To me, the research and practice orientations of education as a discipline need to be balanced and jockeyed back and forth, informing each other. To consider myself a steward of my field, I need to keep the logistics of the enterprise in mind and make sure I’m not becoming too separate from what actually happens on the ground. In other words, I’m afraid of getting too heady and forgetting how to keep it real.
ReplyDeleteWhen examining the word "expertise," I find that I have an extremely difficult time accepting it. I think the fear is that one might feel that they are an "expert," but isn't there always more to learn? I'm in the Curriculum, Culture, and Change track--and I'm finding myself mostly interested in the sociology of education as it relates to curriculum and instruction. While this is pretty narrow, I don't think it is possible to really be an expert in sociology of education--there are always more theories to apply, different situations that might be exceptions, and most importantly, different perspectives from which we can consider the issue at hand. Doctoral work is important; it's important to learn as much as possible about a subject and apply it to our work. After all, without doing some work in the field, we cannot advance education (or medicine, or business, or whatever), but I doubt I will ever consider myself an expert. I feel like if I do, I am resigning the fact that I now know everything (about nothing?) and my work stops. It is important to rely on each other, for it is the body of knowledge that moves the field. Again, we need doctors in any field to help lead the knowledge-making and knowledge-disseminating, but at a philosophical level, I have a hard time accepting that anyone ever obtains "expertise."
ReplyDeleteWow...this prompt struck a tender spot for me. I've been putting off pursuing a PhD for years because I didn't think I wanted the responsibility of being an "expert" in anything. I've been teaching at the college level for over ten years, so I have had a lot of contact with those who possess PhD in a variety of fields, from the humanities to the "hard" sciences. The PhDs I have known are a varied mix; some of them are open-minded and excited about exploring new ideas both inside and outside of their discipline (similar to Pete's description of himself) while others are on the opposite end of the spectrum and pride themselves on being one of the top three most-knowledgeable-people-in-the-world on the random topic to which they've committed themselves. I'm really disturbed by those "super-focused" Phds (to use Kate's words) because they seem more attracted to the idea of being the top-person-ever at something (anything!) than they are to the responsibility that comes along with being "steward," as Richardson says.
ReplyDeleteI really love the interdisciplinary nature of the education field. You come into contact with so many different perspectives here. My background is in English and creative writing, and there are so many unexamined, taken-for-granted "rules" in that field that people look at you cross-eyed if you suggest doing anything differently. I'm sure it's that way in most of our "home" disciplines! Education is exciting because the "stewardship" aspect has the potential to make more change in people's lives than most other academic fields. I'm glad I'm here, in an education program, instead of, say, a PhD in English program, where I would not have a clear "enterprise" to go along with my field.
In response to this prompt, I think it would be fair to assume that I personally see the rewards for acquiring disciplinary expertise as worth the risk for potential unintended consequences. I have considered these consequences, especially in the past year, but in reality they never seemed to cause me much angst. After reading some of these posts I am wondering if maybe I should have worried more; many of you have made some great points that, along with this week's reading, highlight the potential pitfalls of "experts" in our field.
ReplyDeleteI really stopped to think after reading Richardson's passage where she draws on the work of her colleagues Cohen and Ball (page 264). "The virtues of humility, intellectual honesty and integrity, curiosity, and the ability to choose methods without partisan loyalties" need to be built in emerging scholars (or as Kurt calls us in his paper "fledgling scholars") to help counteract a lot of these problems that can arise from expertise that have been stated above. Personally, I still get so excited every time I am able to focus on my own specific research interests within our program, and I often wondered why we did not have even more focused classes in our coursework here. Now I'm starting to realize that this program does a lot to develop the Practical Knowledge and Values that Richardson talks about, and I'm beginning to see the value in those skills. It is better to develop good habits and mindsets as new academics first, and then work toward expertise slowly, deliberately and responsibly.
Taryn Goodwin:
ReplyDeleteUpon entering the Ph.D program, I knew immediately that I wanted to be in the Special Education and Disability Policy track and 'specialize' in the area of special education. However, I told myself I would use this opportunity to broaden my horizons. As a practitioner, I have become know as an 'autism expert' which holds a tremendous amount of responsibility. This identity did not come from a degree in autism, but through practical experience and learning "on-the-job". In the process of becoming this 'expert' I became concerned with the 'marketing' of autism and the fads/misconceptions/beliefs of others. Also, I saw the same trends across other disability populations at different times in the history of the field. I see obtaining my Ph.D. as an opportunity to be the steward, that Richardson defines. I want to be seen as an innovator in special education, not an expert.
In my current job, I participate in systems change initiatives across the state. It is powerful to see learning communities within schools, within divisions, and between divisions changing services for students with disabilities. Not only do I want to preserve this system, I want to enhance it, grow with it, and make best practices a norm, not an anomaly.
With all this said, I worry about being pigeon-holed into 'special education' due to the design of Ph.D. programs. I enjoy the foundational classes where I can complete research projects with other colleagues in the CCC track or educational leadership. I hope that many of us are able to continue our relationship outside of the foundational courses. The different perspectives of my colleagues keeps me open-minded and not so hyper-focused on special education. When I hear other people's ideas, I think how might this impact special education? My goal is to always phrase the question as such, i.e. a cross disciplinary approach. Educational research and practice is to be viewed critically and reflectively, not in isolation.
I agree with the concerns of becoming too focused, but I would argue the actual problems with disciplinary expertise only arise when “experts” have difficulty operating outside the boundaries of their expertise. Like a lot of the comments suggest, a big part of becoming an expert is gaining awareness of the “bubbles” in which we live; but to be good stewards, I think it’s equally important we learn to be conscious of how we operate outside our bubbles. This means being able to say “I don’t know” *a lot* when confronted with new problems, which is something a lot of experts aren’t comfortable with (and I don’t find that surprising – “expertise” is essentially the ultimate goal of an educational system that largely conditions us from day one to believe having the “right answer” is “good” and not knowing an answer is “bad”). This is particularly relevant for me, having dealt a little with STEM faculty researchers in higher ed who are interested in pursuing grants related to educational research. They are all “experts” in their respective STEM fields, having found success in research within various science disciplines – but their effectiveness as stewards of their disciplines (i.e., whether they have won grants to help support and train new members of their fields) has largely hinged on their ability to accept that educational-research lays outside their area of expertise. Those that have worked the hardest to “do it all” have typically gotten the poorest results. -falcon
ReplyDeleteI would echo a lot of what has already been written here. Consequences - both intended and unintended - certainly both exist when becoming an "expert." The intended ones are more obvious - these are the reasons why I have deemed pursuing a Ph.D. to be a valid endeavor and a worthwhile use of my time. However, one major unintended consequence revolves around the idea of making choices. Choosing to become an expert in one thing often necessitates an active choice to not become an expert in something else. My observations and experiences as a teacher in a large urban school district have led me to have many interests related to education. Currently, I am experiencing the tension of this choice. There are two areas that I am considering for possible dissertation topics. Choosing one means that I am actively not choosing the other, and thus choosing to become less of an expert in that domain. The very nature of choosing to pursue one area in depth leaves the unintended consequence of never developing as deep of an understanding in something else.
ReplyDeleteI appreciate that Richardson placed emphasis on the importance of practical knowledge. It is possible for one to become so "superfocused" on what they are studying that they can lose sight of this. I once knew a Ph.D. who was very into abstract theories of learning and this individual was convinced that all teachers should be teaching this way, and not the "old ways." However, this individual had never been a teacher, and thus lacked practical knowledge that might have informed his/her thinking about teaching and learning in ways that could have been more useful for teachers. It is important to not become so much of an expert that one knows "everything about nothing" with regards to real life.
I enjoyed reading my fellow peers' responses and agree with a lot that was already said. My stance on being in any program at any level is that you are there to learn more about a certain topic. Whether it is very focused as Mike feels his topic is, or very broad, there is always more to learn about that topic. That said, I am not sure I believe in "experts" in the sense that they know everything there is to know about their field. I am feeling like a child that is just realizing there might not be a Santa Claus. It is a little disappointing because life could potentially be easier if we could go to the "expert" in a field for all answers pertaining to that field. But at the same time, it is nice to know that people always have more to learn and the answers in that field are not held by a discrete number of people. (And that your questions about those reindeer and how Santa fits down the chimney were not ridiculous.)
ReplyDeleteI have never thought about the potential for unintended consequences in acquiring disciplinary expertise. Do people really feel just because someone has a PhD they know everything about their field of study? I don't think so. Maybe I am not seeing the consequences we are talking about. But with a doctoral degree in education I am willing to learn more and perform research to move the field ahead.
As far as how disciplinary expertise relates to my journey, I did not enter this program because I thought I could become an expert. I want to join the club of people who are passionate about math education and who want to help pre-service teachers as well as practicing teachers learn more about effective strategies. Hopefully as a member of the club I can influence how mathematics is taught to children, but I will never call myself an expert.
Pete, your post definitely struck a cord with me and I completely agree with everything you have said. I, too, am concerned about calling myself in expert in my field. As well, as a student I also fear losing perspective and my own identity. As you said, becoming an expert involves learning from other experts in the field, usually your direct adviser. As students we become experts on the information that our advisers are experts on, and they are experts because of their advisers and so on. I would definitely agree it is good to read sourced that are outside of our advisers interest, outside of our program readings, outside of the school, and even outside of the region or country, allowing us to obtain very different perspectives and not placing is in the bubble that Tammi described in her post. As students we are part of a lineage of experts that believe a particular field or piece of information is more important than the next perspective. We are just heirs of our particular lineage (depending on who's your adviser) carrying on the legacy of our academic ancestors. I sometimes wonder if I had enrolled in another program, attended another university, in another region, in another state would I then be an expert in another field, studying very different information? Very likely. Living in that lineage bubble, and possibly losing perspective of my initial goals and ideas could easily be an unintended consequence that comes with obtaining a doctoral degree and becoming an "expert."
ReplyDeleteRena
ReplyDeleteI do agree with most of my classmates on their views about the doctoral degree and especially with Heather that no matter what program, there is definitely more to learn. Even our professors are constantly learning from each other and the students that they become involved with. So even though somebody might become an expert at one part of a profession, they will still be learning just to keep current, I hope.
Truthfully I have never given much thought to the potential of becoming so much of an expert that it becomes a burden. This is probably because I am in the doctoral program to get the credentials that will enhance my capabilities. Doctoral education is supposed to prepare us to become successful leaders in our fields. I am just glad that the skills and knowledge that I am learning in the Adult learning track seems to translate across a wide range of fields including higher education, human resource development, health education and any other field that involve learning for the adult. As far as research is concerned, I intend to focus on adult learning as it relates to health education but it would not make sense if I was not able to translate my adult learning research to other facets of adult learning, say workforce learning. So I may become an expert in adult health education learning (with room to learn more of course) but I hope it will open up my mind to many more possibilities so that I would be able to translate that learning into other fields of adult learning.